Your Buyer Could Find This. Wouldn’t You Rather Find It First?

by | Risk & Governance

Why CRE Sellers Should Run Cyber Due Diligence Before Listing

If you’re preparing to sell, you already know the drill: clean up the rent roll, get the Phase I current, make sure the lease abstracts match reality, and resolve open maintenance items before a buyer’s inspector finds them. You do it because anything a buyer finds first becomes their leverage, not yours.

There’s one more item that has started to appear on some buyers’ checklists, and most sellers haven’t added it to their routine: a look at the property’s digital and building systems. In our experience, few sellers check for these weaknesses before listing, which means a buyer’s team that does look will find them first, on their own schedule.

What We Mean by a Cyber Encumbrance

ProtectMyIT coined the term Cyber Encumbrance for a weakness in a building’s digital or building systems that could affect a deal: an unpatched server, a forgotten vendor login, an unsecured control system. The word is borrowed from real estate on purpose, but only as a commercial comparison. It is not a legal encumbrance, and nothing is recorded against the title. The parallel is practical: before closing, a buyer wants to know what comes with the building, and these weaknesses come with it.

Where This Stands Today

Let me be straight with you: we’d call this need emerging, not established. Some lenders are putting more weight on cybersecurity in loan origination and refinancing, and cyber insurers are underwriting more selectively, looking for evidence that owners and managers keep core controls over their systems and anything connected to them.

We haven’t yet seen wide adoption of any standard in this area. That said, insurance requirements are changing faster than most owners are tracking, and lenders increasingly want assurance that their investments won’t be burdened with cyber issues. Nobody’s requiring this of you yet – but we believe they will. That’s why it’s worth building the habit now.

What a Buyer’s Team Might Look For

A buyer’s team that reviews digital systems might ask some version of four questions. Many sellers have never had them answered.

How old is the access control system, and what’s it running on?

Badge and access panels are often installed once and left alone for the life of the building. If the server behind one hasn’t been patched in years, that’s a red flag to any buyer who checks.

Can the HVAC and building automation system be reached from outside the building’s own network, and by whom?

Vendor-installed building systems are frequently secured as an afterthought, and a default password or an internet-facing panel is the kind of finding that can become a line item in a diligence report. These systems also often sit in a gray zone where no one has formally defined who owns their security, and a buyer’s team will notice that gap.

Who still has remote access, and should they?

Every elevator contractor, HVAC vendor, and security company that has worked on the property may still hold active credentials. A dozen standing vendor accounts, several belonging to companies you no longer use, is not a good look mid-transaction. Third-party access is also where finance leaders tend to get pulled in, because it ends up in the deal’s financial outcome.

Has there already been an incident nobody flagged?

A prior compromise, even a minor one, that surfaces during diligence raises a bigger question than the incident itself: what else wasn’t disclosed? That question can color every other number in the deal.

The first three questions are also what ProtectMyIT’s BMS Boundary Assessment looks at on an ongoing basis, whether or not a sale is on the horizon.

Why Finding It First Changes the Conversation

I can’t tell you what a weakness in a building would do to a sale price, and we haven’t seen reliable data that would let anyone say. What I can tell you is what it does to a negotiation: it changes who controls the conversation.

When a seller finds a problem first, fixes it, and discloses what remains on their own terms, it becomes a closed topic. When a buyer’s team finds it mid-diligence, it’s an open question with a clock running, and it works like any other diligence finding – a roof nearing the end of its life, say, or a lease that doesn’t match what was represented. The cost isn’t only the fix. It can include lost timing and lost leverage.

A well-known example comes from outside real estate. When Yahoo disclosed prior breaches while being acquired by Verizon, the purchase price was renegotiated down by roughly 7%. That was a corporate acquisition, and it doesn’t tell us what to expect for a building. It does show that a cyber issue discovered during a deal can affect the deal itself.

How Sellers Use a Cyber Encumbrance Assessment Before Listing

A Cyber Encumbrance Assessment is a fixed-scope review, typically run in the weeks before a property goes to market, alongside the rest of the offering memorandum preparation. It inventories what’s connected to the property’s network and who can reach it, checks building systems and vendor accounts for the gaps above, and produces a Cyber Encumbrance Report: a short summary you can include in your offering package or keep ready if a buyer’s counsel asks. It happens once. It doesn’t need to become a permanent security relationship.

Buying Instead of Selling?

Everything above is written from the seller’s chair. If you’re the one buying, the same risk shows up as something you inherit rather than something you disclose: see it from the buyer’s side →

If a property is going to market in the next few months, the cheapest version of this conversation is the one you have before the buyer’s diligence team has it with you.

 

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a cyber encumbrance in commercial real estate?

ProtectMyIT coined the term Cyber Encumbrance for a weakness in a building's digital or building systems that could affect a deal: an unpatched server, a forgotten vendor login, an unsecured control system. It is not a legal encumbrance, and nothing is recorded against the title. The parallel is practical: before closing, a buyer wants to know what comes with the building, and these weaknesses come with it.

Why should CRE sellers run a cyber assessment before listing a property?

When a seller finds a problem first, fixes it, and discloses what remains on their own terms, it becomes a closed topic. When a buyer's team finds it mid-diligence, it's an open question with a clock running, and it works like any other diligence finding. The cost isn't only the fix. It can include lost timing and lost leverage.

What does a Cyber Encumbrance Assessment include and when should it be done?

A Cyber Encumbrance Assessment is a fixed-scope review, typically run in the weeks before a property goes to market, alongside the rest of the offering memorandum preparation. It inventories what's connected to the property's network and who can reach it, checks building systems and vendor accounts for the gaps above, and produces a Cyber Encumbrance Report: a short summary you can include in your offering package or keep ready if a buyer's counsel asks.

Written by: — President / CEO, IBSRE

Mike Mullin leads a mission to help commercial real estate (CRE) owners and operators in Northern New Jersey and the greater New York City area stay protected from the financial impacts of IT disruptions, downtime, and cyber threats. With more than three decades of experience in technology and business operations - including roles at Yardi Systems, First Advantage/SafeRent, and GEAC Computers - Mike brings a well-rounded, practical perspective to IT strategy and risk management. As a trusted partner to CRE finance leaders, business owners, and their partner organizations, he focuses on translating complex technology challenges into real-world solutions that safeguard both operations and financial health.